Skip to main content

The main ingredient is inulin not psyllium. Anyone here use both before and noticed they work the same? I ate the wafers for years and years, ive been experimenting with new fibers lately. Im afted a better quality of life! I got the metamucil clear, its wonderful. Just wanted to reach out and see if anyone had any experience or knowldge on inulin vs psyllium.

Im trying a bunch of new things all around, looking for the perfect 'cocktail'for me. Thanks to all of you i have a nice list of things to try Smiler Im looking to lessen my frequency mainly, and still bulk like the wafers did, with a lot less gas. Anyway, if anyone has some insight on the inulin thatd be great!
Last edited {1}
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Even though it doesn't come cheap, I'd like to give it a shot since the online reviews for it are good. And when it comes to the regular Metamucil, I can feel a difference when I take it but I hate its gritty taste. The clear stuff from what I read has no taste nor is it gritty. I'd like to experiment with it.
I bought the Metamucil Clear last night @ Walmart for $11.84 plus tax, you can round that out to somewhere around $12. It comes in a 11.7 ounce container, so that's almost one dollar per ounce or very expensive compared to the store brand old fashioned Metamucil that can be had for $6.58. But the directions on the Metamucil Clear instruct you to only take one heaping teaspoon of it, that's a lot less than what's instructed to take of the old fashioned Metamucil. So maybe it does give you more bang for the buck. Although I'm still not sure if I can really feel any difference while using it for my first day?

I also wonder if this Equate: 125 Servings Clear Soluble Fiber Powder Fiber Supplement, 16.7 Oz store brand stuff is the same thing as Metamucil Clear? If so it's a real bargain. If I have any good thing to say about Metamucil Clear, it's that its taste is undetectable. That's very good if you ever tried the old fashioned Metamucil.
After what happened to me yesterday after I used Metamucil Clear with my breakfast, lunch, and dinner, it will be a long time before I touch the stuff again. And if I do, I'll only use it with one meal. It just wasn't made for J Pouches. I've never had such a bad case of gas in my life. I would have probably had little to no problem if I didn't have a J Pouch. Gas with a J Pouch can be pure hell though. This was just one more experience that left even more doubts in my head about my J Pouch.
STOP IT! Just stop it Dog Day. Go troll somewhere else. This site has been way too kind to you over the last 12 years. It has let you in again and again after you've done exactly what you're doing right now. Yeah - everyone gets that you don't like your quite well-behaving pouch. Your posts are not helpful to anyone. And they're especially not helpful to those who are contemplating or have new plumbing.

To those reading (and perhaps believing) what Dog Day posts, please take it with a huge grain of salt. His sole purpose is to try to dissuade people from having the surgery or try to make people doubt their choice. He has been banned and removed from this site more times than I can count. If it sounds like he's giving reasonable advice it is purely to draw newbies in so he can play with their heads. This may sound harsh but it is the truth. There are many members here who've had to deal with Dog Day's wrath. (aka FredBird, Ronald McColon and many, many other aliases)

FYI - starting a new product or new food and starting off slowly is something that is mentioned over and over on this site. To denigrate a product or food because one/you went overboard on it is disengenuous. It has nothing to do with reality.

kathy Big Grin
I don't have any experience with what you are going through, and am still waiting to have my take-down on 10/11, but I just wanted to let you know I am wishing you well. I am at a military base, and believe it or not, get a private room every time. My husband has stayed with me for the first few nights of my first two surgeries, and it sure is comforting to have him by my side. I hope you are able to score a private room, but at the very least be able to have your mom stay comfortably with you. Take care!
I just started with the inulin this week (Metamucil Clear) and so far so good. I really like that it just mixes in to something I was drinking already Vs having to make up a special mix with Citrucel or Benefiber. I can't handle the psyllium style Metamucil due to gas from it, so we shall see how it goes with this Metamucil Clear.

Is anybody else having luck with it? Thanks.

Add Reply

Post
Copyright © 2019 The J-Pouch Group. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×