The doc called back and said that it could possibly be the flagyl or maybe even the Cipro or the combination. He advised to stop taking them, which I did a couple of days ago already, and to start taking a few more Lomotil if things start picking up. I had only been taking one a day in the morning.
I asked if this meant that all antibiotics were "off my radar" and he said that other ones are available if need be. I'm hoping that I can dial it in with the Lomotil though.
As of this morning the tingling does not seem as pronounced but I can still tell that it is there when I wiggle my toes or make a fist. It feels kinda like I have my shoes tied too tight (Hello Mr. Obvious) but I get the same sensation when I wear flip flops.
Anyway, thanks again for the responses