I've found this a little hard to come by, but ProShield Plus has never let me down. If you use a very thin layer, it dries and feels a little like rubber. I know this, because I've used it on my upper lip when I've had a bad cold. It prevents the skin from becoming raw and flakey.
Bought a case of it last time I bought it, because Hospitals use it and the inventory is low at times.
I hope you find something that works.
-Roni*